.Whose Religious Liberty?: Christian fundamentalism may inhibit progress, but cannot stop it

As keynote speaker at Notre Dame’s Religious Liberty Summit conference in Rome last July, Supreme Court Justice Samuel Alito said that “religious liberty is under attack.” 

Speaking at an earlier Notre Dame event, William Barr claimed there is an “assault on religion…not decay: It is organized destruction.” When Barr and Alito, Roman Catholics, say religion, their concern is Christianity. They, along with evangelical ministers, regularly claim that their beliefs are under attack, that our modern society is decadent, and the cause of our moral decay is a decline in religiosity. 

Were this claim valid, one would see moral decay paired with increased crime rates. But the data shows something very different. As religious belief has declined, so too have crime rates. And Denmark, Sweden and other western democracies that are far more secular than the U.S. have much lower crime rates. The correlation may be coincidental, but the statistics imply that crime and religious belief go hand in hand. 

Few would think that, but Freakonomics economists Steven Levitt and Stephen Dubner make the compelling case for an indirect relationship. They show that the fall in crime rate is a consequence of Roe v. Wade, which reduced the number of unwanted children who would have been more likely to go astray. Levitt and Dubner’s conclusion is controversial, but if they are correct, future generations will see a rise in crime, due to the Christian crusade, which overturned Roe.

But an even more compelling question is, who is attacking Christianity? Though neither Barr nor Alito provides an answer, hate crime statistics offer some insight. Fifty-eight percent of all hate crime victims were targeted because of racial prejudice, 20.1% because of bias against religion and 16.7 because of discrimination against sexual orientation. 

In the religion category, bias against Jews was most significant at 60%, followed by anti-Muslim at 13%. Christian groups, including Catholic, Protestant and other Christian, comprise 9%. So, of all hate crimes in America, crimes against Christians represent less than 2%. That is a serious matter, but while Jews are nearly seven times more likely to be the victims of hate crime, it is the Christians who complain. Shakespeare would think “Christians doth protest too much.”

Yet as Christians portray themselves as victims, they have steadily gained power and influence. Six of the nine presiding Supreme Court justices are Christian. There was also a majority of Christian fundamentalists in the Trump Administration: Education Secretary Betsey DeVos, Attorney General Bill Barr, Vice President Mike Pence, Attorney General Jeff Sessions, Secretary of State Mike Pompeo, EPA head Scott Pruitt and Housing Secretary Ben Carson…the list goes on. Christians have never been more influential than they were in the Trump Administration, just two short years ago. And Christians still dominate the Republican Party. Christianity is certainly not in any immediate danger.

On the other hand, the number of people who identify as Christian is declining. Christianity, especially fundamentalism, is threatened, not by a group of elitist liberals or some organized conspiracy. Religion is threatened by progress, the advance of civilization and science, especially the advance of secular humanism. Each generation in the U.S. is less religious than the previous.

The War of Independence was much more than a rebellion against King George and repressive taxes. It was an embrace of deism, secular humanism, and the rejection of the oppressive collaboration between theocracy and monarchy that had dominated western culture and denied personal freedoms for 1,000 years.

Secular humanism was conceived in the Enlightenment philosophy of the 17th century and realized in the creation of America, which rejected both religion and monarchy as a foundation for government. From the Revolution onward, personal freedom and human rights have been steadily expanded, ending slavery, securing women’s voting rights, guaranteeing civil rights, permitting interracial and gay marriage, and securing rights for gay and transgender people. Rather than a moral decline, secular humanism has generated a more just society, one that is inclusive, that recognizes that people are simply what nature’s God wants them to be. 

Thinking Christians understand that while Christ’s teaching of love thy neighbor is central to a meaningful life, the fundamentalist world views are no longer relevant. People haven’t lost their way; they have found better ways to understand and cope with the complexities of modern society. Reason and fact have proven more effective than myth and mysticism. Prayer may offer hope and comfort, but modern medicine cures.

The success of secular humanism is further reflected in our increased understanding of the physical world and the advance of technology. Our grasp of relativity, and quantum mechanics along with space exploration, the internet and genetic science attest to the power of humankind’s ability to reason. Whatever one believes God to be, it is certain that humankind has developed, or was given, superior intelligence and the ability to reason, which we appear obligated to use. 

Christian fundamentalism may inhibit progress, but cannot stop it. Banning books, concealing historical facts that make children uncomfortable, or requiring that creationism be taught along with evolution are wrongheaded and futile. As John Adams said, “Facts are stubborn things.” The facts supporting evolution and the facts that led to the Civil War will always exist. Germany sets the right example. There, teaching of the Holocaust is mandatory. Teaching the history of slavery and our treatment of Native Americans should be required here as well. Americans can rightfully be proud of our heritage and aware of our achievements and our failings.

Enlightenment philosophy inspired the founders, but they did not abandon religion. Many were Christian. And Christianity has impacted our culture in positive ways. Martin Luther King, Jr., for example, awakened our collective conscience to the atrocities of Jim Crow. But if Christianity is to be a force for good in modern society, it must reconcile itself with reality and our reasoned understanding of the modern world. 

That may be wishful thinking. Today, white Christian nationals would rather fight, openly opposing humanism. Despite having a secular Constitution, they falsely claim that America was founded as a Christian nation. They criticize Jefferson’s ideas of separating church and state, say that our laws should conform to Christian teaching, and they work to restrict voting rights and personal freedoms. But then, freedom, equality and democracy have never been the goals of Christianity.

By opposing secular humanism, Christian fundamentalists oppose the very thing that inspired the founding fathers and the foundation of America. With their confused and mistaken view of American history, white Christian nationals attack what they claim to be saving. They are on the wrong side of history, and there is no stopping progress. 

Bob Topper is a retired engineer and is syndicated by PeaceVoice.


  1. Great read. I appreciate the courage involved in writing such an article, despite our shared rights as both Americans and free press, to do so. There is no war on Christianity. The folks who claim there is conveniently ignore the fact that religion is, by constitutional law, a completely voluntary endeavor.

    I posit religion is a relic of the past. We once used religion to soothe our ignorance of things we simply didn’t understand. I suspect those sounding the alarm over religion’s fading adherence do so because they’re in jeopardy of losing a once-effective tool, used to control and assuage the masses. There’s also a comforting perception of religion that many folks enjoy, despite it being based entirely on myth. Consider how many secular folks enjoy Christmas, despite the holiday being based entirely upon pagan celebrations that existed long before Christianity.

    It’s curious that US AG and a SCOTUS justice are among those lamenting Christianity’s decline and not the populace, who face far more pressing concerns in their daily lives. It’s abundantly clear that elites have leveraged religion in continuing efforts to oppress women and minorities. Americans know exactly where they stand with regards to religion. Now, if only the elites that run the US government would catch up with the rest of the secular world, we could all move on from the ignorance religion was meant to comfort against.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

East Bay Express E-edition East Bay Express E-edition
music in the park san jose