Unlike revenge, brunch is a dish best served hot off the griddle. Kat’s Kitchen—and not Kat’s Korner, the random name that keeps popping up in my head—is the new Rick & Ann’s. Or, rather, the new tenant at Rick & Ann’s former address. The owners of Kat’s, Victor and Maya Maravilla, decided not to pave over the emotional real estate associated with a gathering place for brunch. Loyal Rick & Ann’s customers can return with a sigh of relief. After refurbishing the interior, the transition to a different brand appears to be seamless. It’s hard to tell that the doors were shut for over a year.
When I walked through the entrance, I expected to get hit by a wave of nostalgia. For decades, I’d eaten at Rick & Ann’s with almost everyone I’ve ever met. Instead it felt like I was eating, not in a parallel universe, but in a vaguely familiar environment. My memories hadn’t been washed away; they were merely being held in a detached state of suspension. The décor isn’t a radical departure from what it used to look like. Both the main dining room and the foyer have definitely been spruced up. The cosmetic facelift presents a cheerful façade, one that’s contemporary, if generically designed for suburbia. Whatever soul or spirit that once gave life to Rick & Ann’s has been thoroughly exorcised.
Chef Michael Fornasero’s breakfast menu is divided into three sections: Toasty, Sweetie and Savory. Two of the dishes pay homage to the previous restaurant. The Boss Hog is a sampler plate with eggs, bacon, sausage, potatoes and toast. R&A’s Doc’s Delight was similarly kitted out but served with a waffle—sans potatoes or toast. I sometimes added a bagel on the side to pair with my poached eggs. The Red Flame Hash, with sweet potatoes, beets, lentils and kale, leans into Mediterranean flavors. R&A’s famous Red Flannel Hash was also made with sweet potatoes and beets, plus red-skinned potatoes and bacon.
When it was time to order I briefly considered the kasha bowl ($13), a buckwheat porridge loaded with seasonal fruit, and a breakfast street taco ($7) before settling on mole chilaquiles ($21). Each brightly colored component on the plate was carefully composed. Pink slices of watermelon radish fanned out against yellow scrambled eggs. Crema and cotija cheese crumbles streaked cilantro leaves and a quartered avocado with white streaks and dots. The housemade blue corn chips, which anchored the dish, were tossed in a mole sauce that was sweeter than it was spicy.
Trout is on the menu twice. On a toast with cream cheese and pickled fennel ($17), and on the Benedict ($23) my friend ordered. She ate every last morsel but said the smoked fish was the highlight of the dish. A pear or apple galette caught my eye in the pastry case on the way in, but we both resisted the temptation and illicit thrill of indulging in any of the many baked goods.
Across town, Shattuck & Butter makes a different version of chilaquiles ($21). The restaurant just opened in Eggy’s old space in the Epicurious Garden, the one in back with patio seating. At the end of August, Eggy’s moved out. It’s preparing to open in Fish & Bird’s former location on Shattuck Avenue and Haste.
Shattuck & Butter’s sprawling menu is totally egalitarian, trying to be all things to all people. Primarily a brunch spot, the owners haven’t changed the look of the place. The food too isn’t much of a departure from what Eggy’s served. From eggs, omelettes, pancakes and waffles to braised short ribs and shrimp po’ boys, everyone’s bases are covered and then some.
S&B’s chilaquiles were less chef-y than Kat’s, more in line with the comfort food served at a diner. The portion was heartier, eggs piled high on a small mountain of chips with a spicy salsa verde. A Mexicali grilled chicken salad ($19) was less successful because it lacked a specific point of view. The plate of chilaquiles didn’t suffer from an identity crisis. But that same humdrum salad has already been made many times over with the same lackluster results.
Kat’s Kitchen, 2922 Domingo Ave., Berkeley. katskitchenberkeley.com
Shattuck & Butter, 1511 Shattuck Ave., Berkeley. shattuckandbutter.com









